Blair's brother wins QC reprieve

Lord Falconer today delayed plans to scrap the title of QC following protests from the legal world led by William Blair, elder brother of the Prime Minister.

The historic title will remain for at least another two years while ministers review an interim scheme.

Under the reprieve, advocates will still be able to use the title.

But the present method of selecting them as members of the Queen's Counsel will be replaced by an accreditation system.

The U-turn announced by the Constitutional Affairs Secretary is a victory for the chairman of the Commercial Bar Association (CBA) - Mr Blair QC.

The title of QC, conferred on barristers who have "taken silk", was suspended by Lord Falconer's predecessor, Lord Irvine, amid complaints that awarding it amounted to a restrictive practice.

But the CBA insists that far from being anticompetitive, the rank of QC "increases choice and commands wide support." In a 168-page response to the proposals, the association says there are a "considerable number of places" where the Government's proposed changes need "modification and clarification".

The QC system, the CBA claims, "is in the public interest, adds value and diversity to our legal system, and performs a significant part in the international provision of UK legal services.

"It is one of the badges of English law internationally. We believe equally strongly that it should be reformed, with appointments made through an independent panel."

Lord Falconer said the new system of appointing QCs would allow greater diversity and fairness.

"The legal system has to put customers first," he said.

"People who buy legal services must be sure they are getting proper value for their money.

"At the heart of the new scheme are a commitment to fairness and openness, a commitment to greater diversity and a commitment to competition."

Under the interim scheme, candidates for QC will be selected after an open competition.

A list will then be sent to the Department for Constitutional Affairs. The department will then pass on the recommendations to the Queen for her formal approval.

Previously QCs were chosen by the Lord Chancellor after "secret soundings" with judges.